Ben Gretch warned that Rashee Rice’s Round-5 best-ball price ignores two red flags. First, any early-season suspension means the sophomore will have to "board a moving train," Mike Tomlin’s term for players trying to re-enter an offense that has already found rhythm without them. Second, Rice’s 2023 fantasy appeal rested on an 81 % catch rate on ultra-short targets (league-low 4.5-yard aDOT), a combo Gretch doubts is sustainable over a full season. With Travis Kelce, new arrival Hollywood Brown and rookies Xavier Worthy and Jalen Royals all demanding snaps, Gretch sees a realistic path where Rice returns, plays fewer routes than drafters expect, and never justifies his mid-round cost. He prefers taking the rookies or even buying Patrick Mahomes naked rather than assuming Rice reprises last year’s volume-plus-efficiency blend.