Theo Gremminger stayed on the RB train by drafting Trevor Etienne to Carolina, arguing the rookie’s 4.3-speed and pass-game chops give him the inside track to overtake Rico Dowdle. Gremminger noted that Dave Canales has a track record of funneling touches to backs who can both run and catch, and the Panthers have added a running back in every off-season window under the current regime. If Etienne secures even a 40% snap share, Theo projects flex-level production thanks to scoring opportunities in a scheme that produced multiple fantasy RB2 finishes for Rachaad White. Dynasty managers should bet on the explosive profile and worry about depth-chart politics later.

Theo Gremminger grabbed Jarquez Hunter and called the landing spot a fantasy gold mine. The Rams traded up for the low-4.4 runner after Blake Corum fell flat and Kyren Williams signed only a short extension. Hunter posted 1,200 rushing yards and eight TDs last year at Auburn, showing compact power that reminded Theo of early-career Darrell Henderson. Gremminger expects Sean McVay to view Hunter as a change-of-pace with genuine takeover potential, slotting him into "high-end handcuff" territory immediately. Any running back who inherits McVay volume has printed fantasy points for half a decade, making Hunter a priority Round-3 dynasty target and a best-ball spike-week pick.

Theo Gremminger selected fourth-rounder Bhayshul Tuten over Cam Skattebo, citing an easier path to touches in Jacksonville’s backfield and Liam Cohen’s obsession with big plays. Gremminger reminded listeners that last year Cohen turned another Day-3 rookie, Buck Irving, into a fantasy league-winner and that both Cohen and GM Trent Baalke mentioned "ability to score from distance" as a priority in their post-draft presser. Tuten averaged over 3.8 yards after contact and posted multiple 50-yard TDs in 2024, traits the Jaguars’ analytics department covets. With Travis Etienne entering his fifth-year option and Tank Bigsby failing to impress, Theo thinks Tuten could carve out the change-of-pace plus explosive-play role immediately and grow into 12-15 touches a game by fantasy playoffs.

Theo Gremminger compared Elijah Arroyo to Terrence Ferguson as a tight-end-premium target but prefers Arroyo after hearing Seattle’s staff wonder aloud in their post-draft press conference if the rookie could "straight-up play X" in the league. Gremminger loved Arroyo’s Senior Bowl tape—highlighting seam-stretching routes and high-point prowess the Seahawks currently lack—and views the landing spot as perfect for immediate down-field targets from Geno Smith. Although Arroyo slid into Round 3, Seattle’s coaching staff publicly emphasized his vertical ability and unique build, suggesting he will see schemed shots rather than the slow rookie ramp most tight ends endure. That blend of draft signal, open depth chart, and explosive usage makes Arroyo a high-ceiling stash in tight-end-premium dynasty leagues.

Theo Gremminger admitted he is backing away from Quinshon Judkins shares after watching the rookie’s post-draft steam push him into the same dynasty range as TreVeyon Henderson, Colston Loveland, and Jackson Dart—three players Theo now prefers. Gremminger was a pre-draft Judkins believer, but Henderson’s first-round capital and all-purpose skill set, Loveland’s tight-end scarcity in premium formats, and Dart’s Superflex quarterback upside make Judkins the odd man out at current prices. In short, the cost no longer reflects Judkins’ uncertainty: he still sits behind Najee Harris for touches, lacks Henderson’s receiving juice, and offers less positional leverage than Loveland or Dart. Gremminger plans to be underweight unless the market cools off.

Theo Gremminger selected Jalen Milrow at 2.11, highlighting an easier path to snaps than people realize. Seattle can save roughly $8 million by cutting Sam Darnold after 2024, and the front office called Milrow one of its top-graded QBs in post-draft pressers. Gremminger expects the organization to give the rookie a late-season audition if Darnold struggles. Because Milrow averaged 7.3 designed rushes per game at Alabama and owns 4.4 speed, Theo views even a two-game cameo as a massive trade window in Superflex leagues. He plans to ride the rushing spike weeks for wins or flip Milrow the moment he’s named starter, calling him the perfect escape-hatch asset at the Round-2/3 turn.

Theo Gremminger said Cam Scataboo profiles as a sneaky second-round dynasty pick even though he only cost early-fourth-round NFL capital. Gremminger pointed out that the rookie’s two elite traits—short-yardage power and legitimate receiving chops—mirror what Tyrone Tracy already does, giving coaches flexibility to alternate full drives rather than pigeon-holing Scataboo into obvious situations. Because that staff struggled to find a dependable early-down back last season, he expects Scataboo to become the go-to option on money downs as the year progresses and possibly seize the entire backfield if Tracy falters. With so few “clean” rookie RB landing spots this year, Gremminger predicted Scataboo will climb into the early-second tier of many Superflex drafts once managers realize the path to 12-15 touches and goal-line carries is wide open.

Theo Gremminger drafted Jayden Higgins at the 2.01 and projected him to slide right into C.J. Stroud’s starting perimeter trio beside Nico Collins. Gremminger noted that Stefon Diggs managed 15.0 PPR points per game in Houston last year on a low-aDOT slot diet, while Tank Dell showed the ceiling of this system two seasons ago. Higgins brings size, an 80-catch season, and a vertical skill set that does not overlap with Diggs or Christian Kirk, making him the natural every-down X the Texans still lack. Theo expects 90–100 targets as a rookie and thinks dynasty managers will start sneaking him into late first rounds by August.

Theo Gremminger said Tyler Warren is worth a mid-first in tight-end-premium dynasty formats because the franchise spent top-15 draft capital on him—higher than any wideout on the roster. Gremminger expects a Tray McBride-style learning curve in 2025 but believes Warren can become the offense’s No. 1 target earner by 2026 once the quarterback room stabilizes. He framed the bet through positional scarcity, noting that a healthy T.J. Hockenson routinely commands a future first-round rookie pick in these leagues. With a profile that includes 85th-percentile burst and a documented red-zone résumé at Penn State, plus the draft signal that the staff wants to feature him, Gremminger is willing to eat a quiet rookie year for multiple top-five fantasy seasons on the back end.

Theo Gremminger slammed the button on Colston Loveland at 1.07 in a tight-end premium format, calling him a slam-dunk long-term asset. Loveland was drafted 10th overall by new head coach Ben Johnson, the same play-caller who unlocked Sam LaPorta’s TE1 overall rookie finish. Gremminger highlighted that Johnson immediately paired Loveland with fellow first-round WR Luther Burden, signaling an offense designed around schemed mismatches. Loveland leapfrogged Tyler Warren in NFL draft capital and lands with a coach who peppers the tight end—making multiple future top-five fantasy seasons a realistic outcome even with target competition early on.

Theo Gremminger selected Tetairoa McMillan at 1.03, projecting an immediate high-volume role with Bryce Young and play-caller Dave Canales. He forecasted 140 targets as McMillan’s rookie floor, with upside to 150-plus given Young’s history of hyper-targeting less dynamic options like Adam Thielen. Theo trusts Canales to scheme McMillan open and prefers the Panther’s clear alpha receiver path over Travis Hunter’s two-way workload uncertainty. The guaranteed volume plus first-round capital gives McMillan a rock-solid floor with WR1 season-long ceiling potential.