Ryan Wormeli strongly recommended buying high on Adley Rutschman despite his good start and inflated price tag. Wormeli highlighted Rutschman's impressive underlying metrics, noting his current .286 batting average has room to improve with an expected batting average of .344. Wormeli pointed out Rutschman's powerful performance in Toronto, hitting two long home runs on opening day, demonstrating he's dialed in and healthy after last year's second-half injury struggles. Wormeli believes Rutschman will sustain and even elevate this early-season success, finishing as the top fantasy catcher in 2025 despite several lineup injuries for Baltimore.

B Wade is high on Adley Rutschman surpassing 1.5 hits, runs, and RBIs against Toronto’s Kevin Gausman. Despite a mediocre historical record batting .190 over 21 at-bats against Gausman, Wade noted that Rutschman battled injuries late last season, skewing his numbers downward. Now healed and refreshed, Rutschman is coming off a superb opener where he collected three hits, three runs, three RBIs, and launched two homers. Given the Orioles’ young, talented lineup, Wade predicts Rutschman’s momentum will continue strongly in this early-season showdown with the Blue Jays, easily exceeding the modest statistical milestone of 1.5 combined hits, runs, and RBIs.

Bryan Zarpentine presents an optimistic prop bet analysis for Adley Rutschman to surpass 1.5 total bases against Blue Jays starter Jose Berrios. Zarpentine cites Rutschman's exceptional career line against Berrios—13-for-22 (.591 average), including two doubles and four home runs—as a significant evidence for the prop. Additionally, Rutschman's impressive spring training (.375 average, 1.033 OPS) further boosts confidence in this opening day bet at plus odds (+130).

Brian Howard expressed significant confidence in Adley Rutschman's hitting performance against Toronto pitcher Jose Berrios on opening day. Citing head-to-head statistics, Rutschman has dominated Berrios historically, batting .591 (13-for-22) with three home runs, three doubles, and notably zero strikeouts in 24 plate appearances. Howard specifically identified value in Rutschman's prop bet at over 1.5 total bases (+120), emphasizing Rutschman's exceptional batting record against Berrios and clear ability to see his pitches well, indicating significant potential for multiple hits or extra-base hits in this matchup. Kyle Purviance further suggested a possible play on Rutschman’s home run prop at +650 as additional value based on these matchup metrics.