Chris Welsh enthusiastically backed Jack Flaherty's betting prop for outs recorded against the Marlins, expecting Flaherty to go at least six innings after consistently hitting that benchmark previously. Although Welsh acknowledged the betting price was somewhat juiced at -150, he asserted confidence in Flaherty comfortably reaching six innings against a favorable matchup. Welsh particularly called out Flaherty's strong historical performance in consistently pitching deep into games and viewed the Marlins lineup as an ideal situation for this wager.

Kenny G recommended betting the Tigers as an underdog (+122), spotlighting Jack Flaherty's impressive start to the season as a key reason. Flaherty carries a strong 2.38 ERA, highlighted by dominant outings against quality opponents like the Dodgers and White Sox, combining to allow just five hits and two earned runs in over 11 innings pitched. Kenny praised Flaherty's ability to perform against tougher offenses, expecting him to succeed against the Yankees' currently cold bats at home, where Detroit remains undefeated early in the season.

Peter Dewey recommended betting the under on Jack Flaherty's hits allowed prop of 4.5. Flaherty has allowed just six hits across 11.1 innings this season, maintaining a stellar 0.88 WHIP. Dewey highlighted the Yankees' recent challenges offensively, emphasizing their mere 13 hits and two runs scored across the first two games of this series. Additionally, he referenced Flaherty's impressive past performance, where last season he gave up only 135 hits across 162 innings.

Greg Peterson advises betting the over 7 runs total in Yankees vs Tigers based on potent hitting and vulnerable pitching. The Yankees have been explosive offensively, averaging 7.1 runs per game and 2.3 homers per contest, despite a shutout yesterday. Tigers starter Jack Flaherty is vulnerable, with a 4.36 ERA in recent starts and notably allowing over 1.6 HR/9 innings for the Dodgers and Tigers. Yankees' Max Fried may look good with a 2.61 ERA but has benefited from four unearned runs skewing his numbers. Peterson emphasizes this misleading factor, noticing Fried's underlying FIP (3.84) is significantly higher than the posted ERA. Given these offensive fireworks and suspect starting pitching matchups, he projects a higher-scoring outcome at 7.8 runs, providing clear over value at 7.

Mike Ianniello expressed strong confidence in pitcher Jack Flaherty, highlighting him as a favorite pitcher to support due to a high strikeout rate. Flaherty's resurgence following past injury issues was underscored by his league third-best 10.78 K/9 rate last season. Ianniello particularly emphasized Flaherty's excellent curveball, which generated a 43.6% whiff rate, as well as his effectiveness in pounding the strike zone with his fastball. These strengths create considerable betting value for Flaherty against a weak White Sox lineup.

Tokyo Brandon identified Jack Flaherty's strikeout prop of 4.5 strikeouts (available on DraftKings) as significantly undervalued, strongly recommending betting the over. Brandon modeled Flaherty for approximately 5.36 strikeouts against the Dodgers in this matchup—well above the listed line—and cited that historically Flaherty has averaged 6.34 strikeouts per start against these Dodgers hitters specifically. Although Brandon still expects Los Angeles to win and Flaherty to concede some runs, he sees considerable betting value in Flaherty surpassing the modest 4.5 strikeout line and made this his second pick for the game.

Brian Howard disagreed strongly with any consideration toward Jack Flaherty as a viable underdog bet against the Dodgers. Howard pointed out that Flaherty's perceived pedigree is overshadowed by repeatedly being listed as a large underdog, indicating limited confidence from sportsbooks. Considering Detroit's weak offensive lineup, he sees virtually no path for the Tigers to win outside of an exceptional Flaherty outing. With Yamamoto's elite stuff for the Dodgers, Howard strongly discouraged taking a chance with Flaherty even at the large plus money odds.

Rob Donaldson prefers betting on Detroit at plus 1.5 runs for three units, projecting a potentially close contest or outright Tigers upset. Despite Yoshinobu Yamamoto's talent and the Dodgers' overall strength, Donaldson insists Jack Flaherty has the capability to outduel star-level opposing starters on the right day. Donaldson emphasizes MLB betting value lies in situations like this, where powerhouse teams still lose 30-35% of games. Additionally, he recommends a smaller one-unit wager on Detroit plus-one, underscoring his confidence Detroit remains highly competitive.