Guy Boston concluded his slate by strongly recommending the under 1.5 hits, runs, RBIs for Jonathan India against the Yankees. He underscored India's pronounced struggles against right-handed pitchers this season, batting just .180 with a low WRC+ of 70.5 in 60 plate appearances. Historical data further supports this fade, as India has just one hit and two strikeouts in three previous plate appearances versus Yankees pitcher Clarke Schmidt since 2018. Although odds are at -145, Guy believes the under presents strong value given India's ongoing difficulties at the plate, particularly against righties.

Guy Boston highlighted Jonathan India as a solid under pick for 1.5 hits, runs, RBIs facing the Yankees. India has consistently gone under, hitting this under 69% of the time this season (11 of 16 games). He's been especially cold recently, going under in eight of his last ten games. Guy also noted recent struggles versus right-handed pitchers with India's low batting average (.196 avg, 76.7 WRC+) this year, suggesting a tougher matchup against Yankees' pitcher Clarke Schmidt. India's previous struggles against Schmidt (one hit in three plate appearances with two strikeouts) further favor betting the under.

Joe Orrico sees Jonathan India as an attractive buy-low, highlighting his new multi-positional eligibility (2B, 3B, OF), improved underlying hitting metrics, and prime batting spot leading off ahead of Bobby Witt Jr. and Salvador Perez. While India has no home runs or steals yet and is hitting below .200, Orrico emphasized positive indicators: career-high hard-hit rate (41%), better average exit velocity (91 mph), notably improved launch angle, and more walks than strikeouts. Orrico projected positive regression with India's expected batting average at .256 and expects him to be a valuable asset going forward, with potential to approach 100 runs scored in an improving Royals lineup.

Final Round offered Jonathan India as a borderline favorable matchup against pitcher Freddy Peralta. India holds a solid career batting average of .375 versus Peralta across eight career at-bats. Though the matchup's overall rating is modest (rated '7' by metrics Final Round employs), it’s still within acceptable playing range. Not considered one of the strongest matchups but deemed usable if seeking additional pieces.