Pat Fantasy Dog Pound said Jalen Tolbert should be near the top of your queue in Underdog’s new Eliminator format. Because the contest cuts the bottom half of the field each week, Pat stressed that drafters need players who can deliver "straight ceiling" games, even if they are volatile from week to week. Tolbert fits that profile, offers late-round cost, and plays in a Dallas offense capable of producing blow-up receiver weeks. Pat called him “the guy” for this structure and urged drafters to grab Tolbert every time they need a cheap, high-variance wideout to keep their roster alive through the weekly eliminations.

Liam Murphy said Jalen Tolbert is "currently the wide receiver two of Dallas" and therefore a late-round name who can supply multiple usable weeks in Best Ball Mania formats. Drafting Tolbert as his seventh wideout lets Murphy remain light at the position while still capturing upside tied to the Cowboys’ starting lineup. He framed Tolbert as a better bet than most receivers in the same ADP range simply because the role is already there rather than hypothetical.