Andy Holloway warned managers not to expect a Tyreek Hill renaissance simply because he is two years removed from a WR1 overall season. Holloway hammered that Hill played all 17 games in 2024 yet averaged just 10.0 PPR points—WR35 on a per‑game basis, behind Adam Thielen—and logged a consistency grade of D with only 29.4 % of outings above 10.5 points. He dismissed the lingering wrist‑injury narrative, noting Hill’s snap share never dipped, and blamed Miami’s philosophical pivot toward short‑area targets for Jonnu Smith and the running backs. Citing how rare it is for receivers past age 30 to rebound after a full‑season drop‑off, Holloway said he is "out" at Hill’s current WR11/early‑second‑round price and would rather chase younger upside plays in both season‑long and best‑ball formats.

Jason Moore flagged Tyreek Hill as one of the biggest red‑flag picks inside the top‑12 wide‑receiver ADP. Moore’s own rank is WR15 after charting a massive efficiency collapse: Hill logged 906 snaps last year—211 more than 2023—but produced 840 fewer yards. He dealt with a season‑long wrist injury and ranked near the top of the league in drops, but Moore believes the larger issue was an offensive philosophy change. Miami stopped pushing the ball downfield, funneling short‑area targets to Jonnu Smith and the running backs, stripping Hill of his superpower of explosive plays (league‑leading 20‑plus‑yard reception rate prior to 2024). With no sign Mike McDaniel plans to revert and Hill entering age‑31 season, Moore warned that drafters are paying 2023 prices for a 2024 role, advising a fade in season‑long drafts unless his ADP slips two full rounds.

Jason Moore urged caution on drafting Tyreek Hill at his customary first‑round price. Hill logged hundreds more snaps last season yet produced barely half the yardage he posted in 2023, despite Tua Tagovailoa staying healthy for most of the year and Miami actually increasing total passing yards. Moore chalked the dip up to age‑related explosiveness loss and a route‑tree shift that pushed more targets underneath. Add in Hill turning 31 before Week 1 and the off‑field uncertainty from another domestic‑dispute report, and Moore slid the speedster down his preliminary wide‑receiver board. He still sees WR1 weeks in Hill’s range of outcomes but prefers younger, similarly priced options and labels Hill a potential overpay in season‑long drafts and best‑ball contests.