Chirimbes laid the 7.5, projecting a 27-19 win. He cited Philadelphia’s league-low three turnovers (two of which came in the first Giants meeting) and questioned whether New York can emotionally rebound after surrendering 33 fourth-quarter points in Denver. With Jalen Hurts facing a reeling secondary and the Eagles protecting the football better than any team in the NFL, Chirimbes expects the favorite to grind out a cover.

Youmans grabbed Giants +7.5, expecting a bounce-back after their meltdown in Denver. He reminded readers New York already beat Philadelphia 34-17 earlier this month and believes the Eagles’ offense is still "out of sync" without injured WR A.J. Brown. Philadelphia owns five wins but none by more than seven points. Conversely, the Giants are "on the rise" thanks to an improving defense and the "dynamic rookie duo" of QB Jaxson Dart and RB Cam Skattebo. Youmans projects another one-score finish and trusts the extra hook.

Joyner noted that the Giants are still reeling from last week’s last-second collapse in Denver, a type of gut-punch loss he says typically carries over. Philadelphia’s passing game finally clicked in Week 7 and its secondary holds the clear edge over New York. Even with Cam Skattebo giving Big Blue a rushing advantage and superior special-teams metrics, Joyner expects a highly motivated Eagles squad to avenge its Week 6 defeat and cover the –7 with a confidence level of 3.

Pamela Maldonado took the Giants +6.5, arguing that Jaxson Dart’s mobility and a punishing Cam Skattebo run game have turned New York into a balanced, ball-control offense. Philadelphia’s defense is surrendering 4.6 yards per carry and ranks poorly on third-down stops, making it vulnerable to sustained drives that shorten the game. Maldonado added that the Eagles are winning with methodical precision rather than explosive plays, limiting their margin for a blowout. In a tempo-driven NFC East slugfest she projects New York to stay well inside the number.

Michael Fiddle recommended Eagles -7 (-105) at home, explaining that a normal three-point switch for changing venues implies the Week 6 closing line (Eagles -7 on the road) was more accurate than the current price. He expects bettors to buy Philadelphia and fade New York as kickoff nears, creating line movement in the Eagles’ favor. Despite the prior 34-17 loss, Fiddle trusts the larger full-season sample over one outlier game and cautioned against parlaying the side and total due to correlation tax.

Tuley grabbed New York +7.5 after the spread climbed from Eagles ‑6 to ‑7.5. Bettors punished Big Blue for blowing a 19-0 fourth-quarter lead in Denver, yet the Giants still covered and had beaten these same Eagles 34-17 just two weeks prior. Tuley isn’t worried about any Philadelphia ‘revenge’ narrative and believes the extra point and the hook represent pure market value in a matchup the Giants have already shown they can win outright.